What Actually Improves Your Odds at Senior Level

(How senior leaders increase opportunity, influence outcomes, and avoid relying on luck)

Senior job searches often feel opaque because outcomes are not driven by effort alone.

Two leaders with similar experience can follow very different paths — not because one is better, but because one is positioned, visible, and present at the right moments.

This page brings together the core factors that actually improve odds at senior level — not hacks or shortcuts, but the mechanics that quietly shape who gets considered, when, and why.

Senior Hiring Is a Probability Game — Not a Merit Contest

At leadership level, hiring is less about ranking candidates and more about managing risk.

Decisions are shaped by:

  • who is known
  • who feels relevant
  • who appears at the right moment
  • who reduces uncertainty

Improving your odds means increasing how often — and how early — you appear in the right conversations.

Positioning: Being Clearly Relevant, Not Broadly Impressive

Strong senior profiles fail when they are too general.

Positioning improves odds by making it immediately obvious:

  • what problems you solve
  • in what contexts
  • for which types of organisations
  • at what stage or moment

The clearer the relevance, the less explanation is required — and the lower the perceived risk.

Timing: Why Opportunity Windows Matter More Than Activity

Senior opportunities are timing-dependent.

Roles emerge during moments of uncertainty — not on predictable schedules.

Leaders who improve their odds are:

  • visible before urgency appears
  • present during early exploration
  • known before a role is defined

This dynamic is explored further here: How Senior Leadership Roles Are Actually Secured.

Access: Getting Into the Right Rooms (Quietly)

Senior roles are rarely decided in public.

Access matters more than volume. Being visible to the right people improves odds far more than being visible everywhere.

Effective access comes from:

  • trusted intermediaries
  • credible referrals
  • early conversations with decision-makers
  • targeted outreach rather than mass exposure

Reverse recruiters work on behalf of senior candidates, proactively representing them to relevant organisations before roles are formally advertised. 

Narrative: Controlling the Story Before Others Do

At senior level, people hire narratives as much as CVs.

Narrative answers questions like:

  • why this person now?
  • why this move?
  • why this scope?
  • what happens if we say yes?

Leaders who control narrative reduce friction, shorten deliberation, and increase conversion once conversations begin.

Leverage: Why Desperation Shrinks Outcomes

Leverage shapes scope, compensation, and influence.

Leaders improve odds when they:

  • avoid urgency-driven decisions
  • create multiple concurrent conversations
  • maintain optionality
  • signal selectivity rather than need

Leverage does not require arrogance — it requires preparation.

Increasing Your Chances Means Increasing Surface Area

Senior leaders often ask, “What’s the best strategy?”

A better question is: “How do I increase the number of high-quality opportunities that can realistically convert?”

Improving odds means:

  • entering more relevant conversations earlier
  • reducing reliance on single outcomes
  • shortening trust-building cycles
  • converting interest into momentum

More surface area creates more chances — and better conversion.

What This Looks Like in Practice

Senior leaders who consistently secure strong outcomes tend to:

  • work proactively rather than reactively
  • engage the market before urgency
  • combine visibility with discretion
  • treat job searching as positioning, not chasing

Want to improve your odds — not just stay hopeful?

A confidential conversation can help you assess positioning, timing, and how to create more opportunities without urgency.

James Gilford – Founder of THM

James, the Founder of THM, is an ex-marketer turned recruiter with over a decade of experience in marketing and digital recruitment. Starting his career in marketing at Nectar Card, he became a top consultant at EMR before establishing the financial services practice at tml Partners. In 2020, James launched THM, working with businesses globally—from startups to corporates—to build exceptional marketing and digital teams.

Follow James on LinkedIn →